
(image: carolita johnson)
Nancy Franklin’s “Women’s Work,” begins her review of Lifetime’s new season of female-oriented shows with an observation that confirms what I thought I might possibly have been imagining: Lifetime is all about reinforcing the fears that discourage women from being as free as they think they are. The killer always turns out to be the boyfriend or husband, and the boyfriend/husband turns out to be the killer or swindler. Women, barricade yourselves, put on your virtual burkas. Men are Bluebeard, or the big, bad wolf in every story. The message is: can’t live with them (because you might be killed or bamboozled big time), can’t live without them (as Maureen Dowd may well know). Now I know why I never liked Lifetime. Is the idea is to use fear to unite women, the easier to suppress them? That would be so old-fashioned that it would nearly be quaint. No, more likely the easier to sell to them. Beware of this kind of “television for women.” It doesn’t have women’s best interests at heart.
Herbert Spencer, a “Man with a plan,” would probably concur, if he were a TV-watcher, which he probably wouldn’t have been had he lived in our times. He observed that:
women manifested “a worship of power under all its forms; and hence a relative conservatism.†Enfranchised women would tend to vote for authoritarian figures, and so obstruct the natural law of progress toward an egalitarian society.
Sound relevant to our times?
Shapin’s exploration of Spencer yields so many contradictory yet sense-making details that you could easily use this piece to answer all the questions in a Keirsey Temperament Sorter. (Spencer would have been an INFJ, if I’m not mistaken). This is a purely gratuitous comment, though, and one and all are welcome to pshaw me. It’s perhaps just a passing thought. In any case, even if you don’t care how Spencer’s evolutionary theory differs from Darwin’s, you’ll realize how much more interesting Spencer was as a personality, and, moreover, be glad you never had to deal with him yourself. Especially if you’re a woman with a big nose, and in love with him.
Say what you will about my fortitude (or lack thereof), but An Error in the Code, by Richard Preston, was much too painful to read. My fingers hurt just thinking about it. I have nothing but compassion for anyone having to live with the compulsive self-destruction discussed in this article. But don’t ask me to read it. Here is an online abstract of the piece, which is not online itself.
In the Fiction, you have to love Hari Kunzru’s “Magda Mandela,” no matter how many times she tells you to “Go now. Go away. Fuck off. Go. I love you. Go.” She likes “a old man.” Oh yes, she does. The f-word makes seven appearances on one page, all very necessary to the plot.
Sasha Frere-Jones has no idea what I’d do without my inner Grinch, but if you want to lose yours, here’s how to do it: Great Danes.
And another great Christophe Niemann illo. Have a look and guess what James Surowiecki’s article is about before you read it.