
I forgot to let you know that I had a cartoon published in The New Yorker last week! It’s not that I like to toot my own horn, but I love to tell the stories behind a cartoon that has struggled a little to get onto the pages of TNY. Formerly rejected in several versions of itself, this cartoon was finally bought after a few re-draws and several re-workings of the caption. (The accepted caption is actually the first version of the caption that I went back to).
Once I sold it, illustration editor Owen Phillips (now at Mens’ Vogue), who had been placed in charge of making sure the cartoonists didn’t slack off—no missing fingers on hands, no blobs in the place of feet, no weird proportions that could just as easily have been not weird—made me re-do the arm on the bride several times. (I’m going to give Owen the Golden Arm award!) He didn’t like the arm being one continuous line on the outer silhouette. I, of course, did like it. Particularly because continuous lines are hard to achieve with the kind of pen you need to dip into ink several times a minute, like the one I use.
Then, once I’d redone the arm to his satisfaction, he noted that the peripheral figures (best man, and maid of honor) weren’t as nicely drawn as in the first, bad-armed, drawing. I decided to push my luck, and pleaded with him that chances were there would always be a shifting of good points every time I re-drew it, and that the peripheral figures were just that—peripheral. He magnanimously let me keep this last version. (Phew!)
So, please note the line break near her elbow. It took all my self-restraint to pick up that pen and start again where I could have kept going and not wasted any ink or movement of my own elbow! And thanks Owen, for making this cartoon very pretty. We miss you! (But you look so good in a tie!)
For an interesting variation on the campfire story of The Golden Arm, see here.