About “freeloaders”
Posted in newyorkette style on Tuesday, Apr. 10, 2007
(“Papers please,” sticker from my illegal immigrant days in France. I “distributed” this one at Immigrations, where an odious one-armed man used to violently reach over his counter and wave my “carte de séjour” application papers in my face while yelling at me till I cried and went home to find more papers. At the student center, even though I had the equivalent of an A average, they used to demand “proof of attending classes.” At both places, young and old alike were often escorted out, crying or screaming obscenities. I stood for this kind of treatment for 11 years. But I digress.)
I just finished reading this article in the Times: U.S. Raid on an Immigrant Household Deepens Anger and Mistrust
Besides the normal feelings of empathy and indignance such a piece would evoke in a normal person, there was one particular bit that struck me as needing extra attention:
Ms. Murphy, who has three children, voiced larger misgivings about illegal immigrants with children in the local school. She called them “freeloaders.â€â€œI’m paying taxes, they’re not,†she said. “Yet their kids still get to go to school with the privileges of my kids. I resent it.â€
As a former illegal immigrant myself (before you get excited, it was not in the USA —I was an illegal American immigrant in France for roughly 6 years overall, with 7 years of legal residence spead out on either side of that time segment), I’d like to point out that most illegal immigrants I’ve known both here and in France are very careful to pay their taxes. Paying taxes does not bring you unwelcome attention from the INS, since the two organizations are not connected, most likely because every country wants every penny it can get, whether it’s from their own citizens or non-citizens desperate enough to pay taxes in order to prove good faith.
Paying taxes provides necessary proof of one’s upright presence in the host country and is very handy when it come to applications for naturalization. The only thing it doesn’t provide is benefits. All those years when I was paying taxes and “charges socials” (social security, etc) while working illegally in France will never ever pay off. Not when I retire, not ever. So, it was my host country that was the freeloader. Not me, the illegal, tax-paying immigrant. And it is the same in every country. We all know what we’re getting into, and we work anyway. When and if we leave the country after spending all our money on food, clothing, rent and other things in that host country (we might send some money “home” or leave with some, but the cost of living and breathing is incurred and paid off in the host country), we also leave behind those benefits. That money stays in the system. Consider it a present.
Those that don’t pay taxes probably don’t make enough to even dream of it: life can be expensive when you have no bank account, no credit record, and you’re paying your rent in cash to landlords who would have you believe they’re doing you a favor (but these landlords aren’t declaring or paying taxes on your rent—the same goes for employers who pay you in cash: they aren’t paying social charges for you either). Those that pay cash to illegal immigrants would have them believe that they could get into trouble for declaring—but in fact, it’s the employers who could get into trouble, too. Where you have an illegal immigrant not paying taxes, you have a Ms. or Mr. Murphey not paying taxes of social charges either. This is also freeloading.
That was for all the Ms. Murphy’s out there. (Hmm, Murphy?—is that a native American name?)













